Dear New York Senators Kirsten Gillibrand & Charles Schumer,
This morning, I heard one of the newscasters say:
“Most American’s do not want the federal government to take over the health care industry.”
I was getting my two youngest kids off to school and getting ready for work, so I don’t know what facts or opinion he was quoting, but I was sure angry that he attempted to speak for me.
I’m American and I indeed, think it is very important for the US government to do something about this mess the health care industry is in and that I have to suffer for.
I have been attempting to call your offices all afternoon, but I either get a busy signal or the call just won’t go through.
I wanted you to know what THIS American has to been dealing with because of the lack of nationalized healthcare for all US citizens:
I was working in a four start local restaurant, full time, for almost three years when I fell off my front porch in October 2007. I was hanging Halloween decorations and ended up fracturing my left humerus in the fall. I went to the ER and they confirmed the break and set my arm and referred me to orthopedics for the follow up care. At the doctor’s office, the conversation went like this as the doctor looked at my X-ray for the first time:
- DOC: This is a bad break. You really need surgery for this. You need a rod
in there. Otherwise you will have less range of motion, your shoulder will
freeze up, you’ll need lots of physical therapy,…- ME: Yeah, well we are
part of the growing group of millions of American’s who have no health
insurance.- DOC: oh…ok, well then, we’ll just wrap it back up and you’ll do
just fine.
I did not do just fine at all.
The cost of surgery was around 30K at that time. The typical procedure is to go in, repair the break with a steel rod and use pins. I had no healthcare offered at my job since it is a small business. My husband was self employed and we could not afford it. Together we made 60 dollars over the eligible limits for Healthy New York. The next self pay group for a family was over 600 a month. Sixty dollars over does not mean we could afford to pay out an extra 500, so none of the people in my family had health insurance. We were self pay and the only thing we could have done was sell our house and live in our car so I could have surgery.
Not a great health care option, but I was going to be fine right?
Wrong.
I am typing this with a broken arm.
After four months in a hard cast, three more in a brace and 120 nights getting “electronically stimulated”, it never healed. The bones click together when I wipe down the kitchen counter or when I brush my hair. I do no have full use of my left arm. My children fight over who gets stuck holding the “broke hand”. I am 41 years old.
Luckily, the economy got so bad here that construction jobs for my husband dried up and with no income we were finally able to fall under the NY definition of poor enough.
Mind you, I have worked since I was 13, pay my taxes, own a home; good middle class values things.. and I vote. It was really hard and rather demeaning to jump through all the hopes.
Currently, I only have to wait for my cards to come in. I was told they should be here by June. I would like to be treated like a human being worthy of care. I would like to know when I will be able to raise my arm up again. I would like to be able to hammer a nail in a wall. I would like to be able to swim with my children again. Now the surgery will cost around 40K as they need to chip out what bone did grow and user cadaver bone grafts as well. And I will need more physical therapy since my arm has been only half working for over a year and a half.
It’s wrong that I have been denied a basic medical procedure because of my lack of insurance. I know it’s supposed to be my fault somehow that I didn’t have any. If I had a better job than I would have been ok, right?
But I have a better job now. I am the Director of Social Media at an Internet Marketing Firm ( a job I do with one hand!) Today, the insurance reps came in to talk to my office about the ever changing options available. And for just ME to be insured is about 20% of my income a month. For my whole family the cost of health insurance is over 1/3 of my paycheck. It’s more than my mortgage! Are you going to cut cost 50%? Because even then I could not opt in unless someone took over my food bill.
Even now that it is offered, we still cannot afford it and it is the most horrible plan ever! Even if the current administration cuts prices the plans are still insane. This one they were pushing had a 10k deductable for a family.. so I pay out over 10K a year, pay for everything until I hit the 5K deductable and THEN my insurance kicks in?? It’s illogical! Most people will see that they do spend more than 15K a year seeing doctors.
Please think of me, think of a mother of four; working, driving, doing laundry, and washing dishes.. all with a still broken humerus that hurts every day and vote for a huge change!
Fix it and give us American people the national healthcare we deserve!
Thank you,
Claudia Corrigan D’Arcy
Kingston, NY
Hey there, stop by your blog often and as a Canadian, just wanted to say. . .push for that health care! The lies that have been peddled to you about our system in the name of “sober facts”. . .I could go on forever. I access the Canadian health care system on behalf of myself, my soon-to-be-12-year-old daughter with severe asthma, and my 62-year-old autistic brother with many health issues. I accompany both of them on appointments to specialists and hospitals and know the system intimately. It boggles the mind that not only do you not have proper health care, many in your country are actively resisting it as some nefarious plot.
Do you have any idea what it’s like as a single mom to wake up every morning knowing your kids can get any treatment and any surgery that day and all you have to do is flash a card? I just despair for your country at times. My parents were American and I’m sure they would be horrifed to hear me say this. But wtf. Dump the guns. Get the health care.
We don’t have nationalised healthcare here, but enjoyed its benefits in the UK.After watching Sicko, I was even more convinced that that’s the way to go.We also don’t have medical insurance so I am so grateful we’ve not had to go through what you’re going through.There’s no way we’d survive…I wish every country in the world had it.Though of course with my dear continent not being exactly rich it probably wouldn’t make a difference, but it would be a start!
As another Canadian with the ability to “Flash a card” to ensure myself and my family can receive any type of healthcare we require, I find it unfathomable, that there are politicians in the U.S. who equate free healthcare with the “evils of socialism.” GET REAL, letting people die because they cannot afford healthcare is the real evil here. Amazing to me that the U.S. government feels it can “fix” every other country in the world, but they can’t fix the fundamentals for their own citizens. It is deplorable to say the very least.
My son is unemployed and has no medical insurance. He is currently attending school to get a better job. More and more people are losing their jobs and their health coverage. Yesterday I was at a luncheon and had to sit through two people going on about how they do not want “socialized medicine” here in the USA. Easy for them to say, who can afford medical care. It made me sick to listen. Claud, what happened to you is a tragedy and should not happen, but it does every day in the USA until health care here gets fixed. Yayyy Canada!
Preview
Kippa said…
I’m SO grateful I live in a country where the health care system is founded on the principle of universality – and sad and angry on behalf of those who don’t. Any country that presumes to call itself civilized should be able to offer its citizens decent medical care. I don’t know where we’d be without it.
Not true. I do have some idea and it’s scary to think about.
Canada’s health care system gets dissed a lot by certain smug USians who live on easy street. And sure, Canada’s not Utopia.
But it’s on the whole our system is pretty damn good.
And compared to the US it’s fabulous.
I am so sorry about your arm, Claud.
You deserved proper care.
You all are making me seriously wish I was living a wee bit north and saying “eh” more often…
I hate these freaking politicians that look down on what obvioulsy WORKS in Canada!
It is appalling how people are treated in the U.S. when it comes to health care. Capitalism may make business hum, but it cannot provide for basic human needs such as food, housing, and health care. It lets MANY fall through the cracks. One needs a social safety net, universal coverage, to ensure that no-one is left behind. And isn’t that the overall ideal goal?
Check out our Medical Services Plan rates here in BC:
http://www.health.gov.bc.ca/msp/infoben/premium.html
And there is “premium assistance” for the poor. No-one is left behind.
Two of our federal New Democrat politicians are in the U.S. right now addressing the myths and lies that are being spread about the Canadian health care system. You would be an excellent “poster child” for what’s happening with the U.S. system.
Contact Jack Layton at laytoj@parl.gc.ca and info@jacklayton.ca and tell him your story. With luck, his staff should be able to pass your email on to him.